Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Movies

In reply to the discussion: Movies you think are over rated [View all]

PJMcK

(23,422 posts)
28. Arthur C. Clarke wrote 4 novels in the series
Sun Dec 15, 2024, 10:42 AM
Dec 2024

The first is brilliant and provides an epic view of life in the universe. It is one of the greatest science fiction novels ever written.

But the series goes down hill from there.

2010 is a decent novel although the "ghost" of David Bowman adds a mystical layer to what had been a strictly scientific tale. The film is far inferior to the novel, in my opinion, even though Roy Scheider is one of my all-time favorite actors, (narration is ALWAYS a poor substitute for active story-telling).

2061 goes even further into weirdness but nothing tops his final novel in the series, 3001. Guess what they find floating in deep space? Frank Poole's body which has been floating in deep space for a thousand years! Incredibly, he is re-animated and brought back to life. He's rehabilitated and studies to get up to speed in the advanced new world. Then he goes back to Europa and figures out how to block a computer program left behind by the aliens who seeded intelligent life on Earth, (remember the ape scene in 2001?). Bowman's "ghost" teams up with Poole to inject the virus into the alien system which destroys all of the monoliths. As they calculate where the aliens came from they determine that Earth has 400 years to prepare for the aliens' return when they will supposedly destroy humanity because we've grown into an evil force.

Okay.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Love Actually. I can't stand that movie. jimfields33 Dec 2024 #1
lol jfz9580m Dec 2024 #4
Oh, totally agree. And tis the season. Scrivener7 Dec 2024 #12
Funny you should mention it XanaDUer2 Dec 2024 #23
Same here. Ocelot II Dec 2024 #26
The Godfather Bok_Tukalo Dec 2024 #2
Ooh those are good ones too.nt jfz9580m Dec 2024 #5
I feel like I'm missing something watching that movie. Shermann Dec 2024 #10
Anything with Katherine Hepburn. n/t SheilaAnn Dec 2024 #3
Sorry but, "2001 a Space Odyssey". I thought it was very slow and went to sleep in the middle of it. Walleye Dec 2024 #6
It was pretty epic for its time but maybe hasn't aged that well. Shermann Dec 2024 #7
My favorite movie of all time! bif Dec 2024 #17
Have you seen the sequel? Sector 001 Dec 2024 #19
Thanks for the recommendation, I'll keep an eye out for it Walleye Dec 2024 #25
Arthur C. Clarke wrote 4 novels in the series PJMcK Dec 2024 #28
I agree. PoindexterOglethorpe Dec 2024 #24
Forest Gump... lisa58 Dec 2024 #8
For me, it is "Silence of the Lambs" Jodie Foster collaborates FSogol Dec 2024 #9
Silence of the Lambs is pretty cool but confusing Shermann Dec 2024 #13
Cell phones would've eliminated the last scene. My #1 movie theater experience underpants Dec 2024 #18
Inception. Ugh. Scrivener7 Dec 2024 #11
Most all of them bucolic_frolic Dec 2024 #14
Gone with the wind. The Ten Commandments. underpants Dec 2024 #15
C'mon, that had John Wayne as a roman centurion, "Truly he wuz the sun of gawd!" FSogol Dec 2024 #27
😎 underpants Dec 2024 #33
Oops, no worry, both were grade A cheese. FSogol Dec 2024 #44
The Searchers Mike Nelson Dec 2024 #16
The Godfather Jrsygrl96 Dec 2024 #20
I haven't seen Goodfellas, but I love The Godfather. ificandream Dec 2024 #42
Star Wars: The Force Awakens Shermann Dec 2024 #21
The Way We Were no_hypocrisy Dec 2024 #22
You must not be an eighth grade girl. murielm99 Dec 2024 #29
I only saw it a few years back, so I had heard about it for decades. Xavier Breath Dec 2024 #41
Damned near every highly acclaimed drama I've ever suffered. hunter Dec 2024 #30
Out of Africa CanonRay Dec 2024 #31
Not on my top ten list, but I liked it. Ocelot II Dec 2024 #35
"Pulp Fiction" and "Wolf of Wall Street" Mike 03 Dec 2024 #32
Agree on two. underpants Dec 2024 #37
Titanic. greatauntoftriplets Dec 2024 #34
Overrated, but worth watching once. I agree that it was too long. Ocelot II Dec 2024 #36
Not overrated but I was like that with Pearl Harbor. underpants Dec 2024 #38
Anything with Adam Sandler or Jim Carey bif Dec 2024 #39
For recent movies, it hast to be Barbie. Xavier Breath Dec 2024 #40
"The Three Stooges" ificandream Dec 2024 #43
Another vote for Forest Gump - it required way, way too much... 3catwoman3 Dec 2024 #45
Latest Discussions»Culture Forums»Movies»Movies you think are over...»Reply #28