Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Diamond_Dog

(36,480 posts)
4. Can you use half butter, half coconut oil?
Sat Mar 22, 2025, 11:10 PM
Mar 22

I have had good results making cookies with those ingredients.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

I have a grandchild allergic to soy. I have had good KitFox Mar 22 #1
That's one of the ones I used, (couldn't remember the names,) but the cookies tasted funny to me. HeartsCanHope Mar 22 #6
I have hypothyroidism, too. Taken meds for almost 40 years n did not know about soy.. Deuxcents Mar 22 #2
I take levothyroxine. I was told no soy, soy lecithin, walnuts and cottonseed oil. HeartsCanHope Mar 22 #7
No caffeine and no otc meds..labels advise it, also. Deuxcents Mar 22 #14
There are great vegan options... buzzycrumbhunger Mar 22 #3
Thanks, I'll look into this! Not a fan of coconut, but if it doesn't taste like coconut I'll give it a whirl. HeartsCanHope Mar 22 #8
I despise coconut... buzzycrumbhunger Mar 22 #11
I used to love coconut as a child, but can't stand it now, too sweet. HeartsCanHope Mar 23 #26
Can you use half butter, half coconut oil? Diamond_Dog Mar 22 #4
Well, that's the second suggestion for coconut oil, I'll look into trying it. HeartsCanHope Mar 22 #9
I doubt if there is enough of anything but fat in crisco to influence thyroid function Kali Mar 22 #5
I have cholesterol issues, so don't think that lard would work for me. HeartsCanHope Mar 22 #10
you sent me off on a search Kali Mar 22 #12
have you tried ghee? WhiteTara Mar 22 #13
No, I have not. There is a huge Asian Supermarket about 45 minutes away. HeartsCanHope Mar 23 #15
If I am baking, I use lard. marble falls Mar 23 #16
I used to cook pies with lard, but with my cholesterol problems, and Type II Diabetes, it's not an option anymore. HeartsCanHope Mar 23 #17
The problem I have with vegetable o is that they take a poly unsaturated fat and saturate the fat by adding ... marble falls Mar 23 #18
added: I never realized there was soy oil in Crisco - I always thought it was cotton seed oil. marble falls Mar 23 #19
Doc said no to either one! Says either one makes the meds less effective. HeartsCanHope Mar 23 #22
I won't consume either voluntarily. They both have seriously bad things about them without adding the ... marble falls Mar 23 #23
You can easily make your own ghee buzzycrumbhunger Mar 23 #29
Thank you for this! I'll have to try it. You are so kind! HeartsCanHope Mar 23 #30
Sweet Potato/Carrot Fat Substitute for Recipe (food.com) eppur_se_muova Mar 23 #20
Interesting. It would definitely effect color. HeartsCanHope Mar 23 #21
Have you tried Earth Balance soy free sticks? Ziggysmom Mar 23 #24
I have not! Another item to add to my list to try. HeartsCanHope Mar 23 #25
I'd try discussing it with a different doctor. nilram Mar 23 #27
Hi! I also have hypothyroidism and take levothyroxine. MLAA Mar 23 #28
try lard. i prefer pork. but its pretty much tasteless + crisps. might need salt. it is better for you. pansypoo53219 Mar 24 #31
Thanks for your suggestion. Everyone has been so kind! HeartsCanHope Mar 24 #32
Latest Discussions»Culture Forums»Cooking & Baking»I can't use Crisco shorte...»Reply #4