Latest Breaking News
In reply to the discussion: Nobody needs AI to search the Internet, court says in ruling against Google [View all]reACTIONary
(7,361 posts).....the host will die, and it will become obsolete. We will all go back to some golden age, and become smart again.
But I doubt that. It's just a new thing and new things often cause unwarranted concern, and even panic and fear.
Search: Mathematicians protesting calculators
WARNING - AI Response:
The most prominent historical protests against calculators by mathematicians and educators occurred in the 1980s. These protests were primarily led by educators and traditionalists who feared that the introduction of calculators would cause students to lose foundational mental math skills and numerical understanding.
The 1986 NCTM Protest - The most famous of these demonstrations occurred during the April 1986 annual meeting of the National Council of Teachers of Mathematics (NCTM) in Washington, D.C.
The Catalyst: The NCTM released recommendations advising the integration of calculators into math classrooms, even in early elementary grades.
The Protest: A group of concerned math educators and mathematiciansmost notably led by John Saxon, author of popular math textbookspicketed outside the meeting.
The Arguments: Protesters carried signs warning that "calculators are crutches that will cripple our kids' minds" and argued that rote memorization and manual calculation were essential to cognitive development. They argued students shouldn't use calculators before mastering mental math and basic arithmetic.
The Lasting Debate - This historical standoff represents a classic clash between embracing new technology and preserving traditional educational methods.
The Pro-Calculator Stance: Educational bodies like the NCTM argued that calculators freed students from getting bogged down in lengthy computations, allowing them to focus on higher-level mathematical problem-solving and concepts.
Modern Parallels: This historical friction over calculators is frequently compared to modern debates over artificial intelligence and tools like ChatGPT in the classroom.