Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Boo1

(829 posts)
17. More BS of people asking a democrat to do the impossible
Sat Jul 11, 2026, 12:42 PM
Saturday

And being upset that they don't.

You can't appoint somebody to a seat that is already filled. Even if McConnell is being kept alive by machines, he is still alive and his seat if filled. There is not a mechanism to replace a congressman due to incapacitated other than a regular election. The seat opens on term, resignation, expulsion, or death. Nothing else.

And even if McConnell were replaced with a Democrat today it would change nothing about the calculus in the chamber. Republicans would still hold the majority with the exact number of votes they have available with his laying in a hospital bed. Republicans are already down a vote.

For them it would be better to have him die and tey to force a replacement picked by KY legislature. They have nothing to lose in that fight, as described, and a good chance to pick up a maga vote in his place.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

He can't appoint a new senator. LisaL Friday #1
Correction: Mitch McConnell took that power away from him. Chasstev365 Friday #2
Even when Beshear had the power, he was required to appoint a Republican onenote Saturday #18
The situation is a bit more ambiguous mr715 Friday #3
i don't think so orleans Friday #8
U.S. Senate seat is a state at large office. pat_k Saturday #11
The KY constitution also refers to "district" offices. onenote Saturday #12
When the seat is vacated, he will challenge the unconstitutional 2021 and 2024 laws pat_k Friday #6
But McConnell is federal, not state. LisaL Saturday #9
U.S. Senate seat is a state at-large office. pat_k Saturday #10
In order to apply the KY constitution consistently and in accordance with the US constitution onenote Saturday #13
That's what the challenge would test. pat_k Saturday #14
Do you think there is any question that KY cannot give governor authority to appoint a US House District member? onenote Saturday #15
Well, if Mitch is "recovering" under "excellent care" until 1/3/27... pat_k Saturday #16
Just bring in a bunch of people to a rally, say it's gonna be wild, then storm the hospital. RedWhiteBlueIsRacist Friday #4
A superlative suggestion, sir. with just two minor flaws. One, he doesn't have legal authority to do so. And two... krawhitham Friday #5
The first vacancy he will challenge the law as a violation of the state constitution. pat_k Friday #7
More BS of people asking a democrat to do the impossible Boo1 Saturday #17
The point would be to force a KSC ruling on the constitutionality of the restrictive law. harumph Saturday #20
You all must understand that the KY Supreme Court is favorable to Beshear and Dems Wanderlust988 Saturday #19
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»This message was self-del...»Reply #17