Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Ms. Toad

(37,338 posts)
48. This was based on an appellate court decision about a decade ago.
Fri Jun 27, 2025, 11:40 AM
Jun 27

The supreme Court denied cert.

I don't disagree that there is racism involved in almost everything this administration does.

But unlike the instances where they are just grabbing brown people off the streets, this is an instance in which courts had already adjudicated his citizenship. By the time it got to the courts, he had already committed at least one crime (I don't recall the details, which made him ineligible for naturalization. But something felt legally off about the story, so I went to the original article, and then to the case. From the case, I immediately recognized it was the same argument raised against Obama which would have made him ineligible to be president had the lie (that he wasn't born in Hawaii) been true. I researched that tables me of laws extensively at the time

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Kick dalton99a Jun 26 #1
This came up when mccain ran for prez. The issue was decided in his favor. Karadeniz Jun 26 #2
Yet this Austin newspaper is dated June 2025 IrishBubbaLiberal Jun 26 #4
The issue was only ever a political smear, but it was hashed out in public anyway... Hekate Jun 26 #12
State Department JustAnotherGen Jun 26 #29
My God iemanja Jun 26 #3
That's what I thought, too! ShazzieB Jun 26 #20
No SARose Jun 27 #51
I feel so bad for this guy sdfernando Jun 26 #5
How did he get back as a kid ? JustAnotherGen Jun 26 #31
The same for me sdfernando Jun 26 #36
I have a certificate of citizenship because my father insisted on it Picaro Jun 26 #6
My ex-husband and my son's father (white) was born on an Air Force base in England. Does this mean he's an illegal? sinkingfeeling Jun 26 #7
First I'm hearing of this..I think..a few posters are leaving. I'm without words so pissed Deuxcents Jun 26 #14
It's not being born on a military base that is the issue. Ms. Toad Jun 26 #18
1973 JustAnotherGen Jun 26 #33
The rules are different with only one American parent. Ms. Toad Jun 26 #38
Tammy Duckworth JustAnotherGen Jun 27 #43
She can't change the courts interpretation on the Constitution Ms. Toad Jun 27 #46
Indeed JustAnotherGen Jun 27 #47
wrong SonOfNebanaube Jun 26 #35
Did you read the case? n/t Ms. Toad Jun 26 #37
Maybe things have changed JustAnotherGen Jun 27 #44
What they are showing us here is, they can do anything to anyone at any time questionseverything Jun 26 #8
Wasn't Sen John McCain born overseas as his father was in the Navy? surfered Jun 26 #9
Born in Panama UpInArms Jun 26 #11
Panama was under US control at the time, Ms. Toad Jun 26 #17
John McCain UpInArms Jun 26 #10
My brother was born in the Middle East drmeow Jun 26 #13
Not the same issue - Ms. Toad Jun 26 #16
deporting someone to a country he has never been in Skittles Jun 26 #25
And how does that make the citizenship of a Ms. Toad Jun 27 #39
I have two brothers born overseas to my military dad Skittles Jun 27 #40
This was based on an appellate court decision about a decade ago. Ms. Toad Jun 27 #48
This is the same issue alleged with Obama - Ms. Toad Jun 26 #15
So how did he end up in Jamaica? forgotmylogin Jun 27 #52
His father was born in Jamaica. Ms. Toad Jun 27 #53
Okay, that at least sort of make sense. forgotmylogin Jun 27 #54
Take Ted Cruz. No seriously, take him. OnDoutside Jun 26 #19
Welcome to the Fascist States of Amurka. paleotn Jun 26 #21
I remember Rebl2 Jun 26 #22
she's the right color Skittles Jun 26 #26
Well Rebl2 Jun 26 #27
that would not surprise me one bit Skittles Jun 26 #28
I'm a Citizen Born Abroad. bluedigger Jun 26 #23
Me too CozyMystery Jun 27 #45
The law is lagging SpankMe Jun 26 #24
" immoral, cruel, devoid of compassion" Skittles Jun 26 #30
Good grief wendyb-NC Jun 26 #32
This is beyond fucked up. Especially after hearing the full story of how he was detained by ICE in the first place tulipsandroses Jun 26 #34
Yet the public and the press will still believe that the right supports the troops. LonePirate Jun 27 #41
This administration is pure evil! Initech Jun 27 #42
The Land of the Free....is false advertising. Ping Tung Jun 27 #49
My Dad was a Vietnam Veteran. And my brother was born in Frankfurt, Germany. Aristus Jun 27 #50
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Deporting children of mil...»Reply #48