Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

iemanja

(57,314 posts)
Sat Dec 6, 2025, 05:14 PM Dec 6

Help with litter boxes

I’m thinking of getting a cat and would like to get a self-cleaning litter box. The problem is that I don’t have $650 to spend on the best rated one, Whisker Litter Robot 4. Some of the cheaper ones ($100 +) get poor reviews.

What do you do for a litter box? Any suggestions for how I can get an option that is minimal hassle without breaking the bank?

43 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Help with litter boxes (Original Post) iemanja Dec 6 OP
I have the Litter Robot 4.... FarPoint Dec 6 #1
We have a cat boarding business in our home Iwasthere Dec 6 #2
What is the brand name? iemanja Dec 6 #4
Called Natures Bedding. Heres a link Iwasthere Dec 6 #38
TY. Do you add it to other litter? iemanja Dec 6 #39
I use an old fashioned litter box with World's Best flushabke litter. Keep next to toilet SheltieLover Dec 6 #3
I looked online iemanja Dec 6 #9
World's Best Cat Litter. Chewy has it SheltieLover Dec 6 #10
Ok. Thank you! iemanja Dec 6 #11
Yw SheltieLover Dec 6 #12
Please consider carefully TommyT139 Dec 6 #18
Yes, I was thinking about that iemanja Dec 6 #19
I wouldn't recommend flushable if you have a septic tank or sand mound biophile Dec 6 #27
I don't have a septic tank, but I have a very old house iemanja Dec 6 #29
curious if you have ever had a cat before Skittles Dec 6 #5
Yes, and I hated dealing with the litter box. iemanja Dec 6 #7
OK yeah, well then yeah, I get it Skittles Dec 6 #13
We've dealt with several for a lot of years... slightlv Dec 6 #23
Over the years... buzzycrumbhunger Dec 6 #6
Could you possibly link to the one you have? iemanja Dec 6 #8
Yup! buzzycrumbhunger Dec 6 #14
Thank you! iemanja Dec 6 #15
YW! buzzycrumbhunger Dec 6 #17
This message was self-deleted by its author iemanja Dec 6 #20
I also use a sifting box Freddie Dec 6 #16
That arm and hammer system looks good iemanja Dec 6 #22
Do you think a crystal litter would work with that sifting system? iemanja Dec 12 #42
Try it, let me know how it works! Freddie Dec 12 #43
Sweet quilt behind them. Beautiful cats. Srkdqltr Dec 6 #21
Thanks! buzzycrumbhunger Dec 6 #25
Good for you doing that, makes it precious. Srkdqltr Dec 6 #37
Your kitties are beautiful! 50 Shades Of Blue Dec 6 #26
Disposable box? Dear_Prudence Dec 6 #24
I decided to go with a sifting litter box iemanja Dec 6 #28
Good choice! nt Dear_Prudence Dec 6 #32
Disposable boxes are bamagal62 Dec 6 #34
We use the litter boxes with the high sides so kitties can't get litter on the floor when they dig. Nanuke Dec 6 #30
Recently switched to a brand of litter called "Catalyst" Blue Owl Dec 6 #31
I use a disposable litter box. bamagal62 Dec 6 #33
Also, one more warning about bamagal62 Dec 6 #35
If I do get a cat, I'll go with a sifting box rather than clumping iemanja Dec 6 #36
The clumping litter can be heavy CountAllVotes Dec 6 #40
Thanks everyone. I ordered the litter box iemanja Dec 6 #41

FarPoint

(14,481 posts)
1. I have the Litter Robot 4....
Sat Dec 6, 2025, 05:16 PM
Dec 6

two cats.....I find this littler box to be my favorite domestic tool in my home.... Winner-Winner....

I do know other folks who have previous models and do fine with there box....

Iwasthere

(3,478 posts)
2. We have a cat boarding business in our home
Sat Dec 6, 2025, 05:23 PM
Dec 6

Happy Cats Hotel in Oregon (albeit we are selling it, on bizbuysel). Anyway, we have always used basic chemical free pellets. Far less messy and virtually no smell. Unsure how it works, you'd think it would be smelling. So easy and a whole lot cheaper. Just put a cup into the tray and it'll kinda fluff up when wet then dump out the entire tray. Doesn't break the bank.

Iwasthere

(3,478 posts)
38. Called Natures Bedding. Heres a link
Sat Dec 6, 2025, 09:09 PM
Dec 6

[link:Nature's, Bedding Pellets, 40 lb | Bedding Pellets | Wilc... | Shop Home, Backyard, Pet, Farm & Rural Lifestyle - Wilco Farm Stores https://share.google/dZA7ym0FnbOLztR12|

SheltieLover

(76,133 posts)
3. I use an old fashioned litter box with World's Best flushabke litter. Keep next to toilet
Sat Dec 6, 2025, 05:24 PM
Dec 6

for easy scooping. It clumps very well & is made of ground corn cobs so it is low dust & flushable.

iemanja

(57,314 posts)
9. I looked online
Sat Dec 6, 2025, 05:41 PM
Dec 6

and can’t find one called flushable. What is its exact name? Sorry to be a pest about it.

SheltieLover

(76,133 posts)
10. World's Best Cat Litter. Chewy has it
Sat Dec 6, 2025, 05:44 PM
Dec 6

I use the multi cat formula as it seems to clump very nicely.

Hard to describe, but it clumps so well I only have to wash the box once a week or so.

Also, it does not have those chemical crystals in the litter, yet does not smell.

TommyT139

(2,134 posts)
18. Please consider carefully
Sat Dec 6, 2025, 06:05 PM
Dec 6

Besides plumbing issues (depending on what sort of system you have), flushing cat poop can be quite harmful if your waste stream goes out to an area where sensitive animals reside, especially otters.

https://iere.org/what-happens-if-you-flush-cat-litter/

There is also some risk to humans from toxoplasmosis, but the risk to otters can have a bigger impact.

biophile

(1,164 posts)
27. I wouldn't recommend flushable if you have a septic tank or sand mound
Sat Dec 6, 2025, 07:18 PM
Dec 6

Sure you can flush it but it will gum up your sewer system eventually, probably sooner than later. If you have a city sewer line, it might not be a problem.

Skittles

(169,244 posts)
5. curious if you have ever had a cat before
Sat Dec 6, 2025, 05:30 PM
Dec 6

barring health issues, I really don't get the angst over a litterbox - they literally take a minute to scoop, then you dispose. I have had to do several litter boxes at one time and it really wasn't that big of a deal.

iemanja

(57,314 posts)
7. Yes, and I hated dealing with the litter box.
Sat Dec 6, 2025, 05:38 PM
Dec 6

This was about 40 years ago, so I know technology has improved since then.

Skittles

(169,244 posts)
13. OK yeah, well then yeah, I get it
Sat Dec 6, 2025, 05:48 PM
Dec 6

oh and I wasn't aware the self-cleaners cost so much, that seems a bit......ridiculous

slightlv

(7,396 posts)
23. We've dealt with several for a lot of years...
Sat Dec 6, 2025, 06:21 PM
Dec 6

never quite made it the "one per cat, plus one extra" formula, tho. Used to be no issue until my disabilities kicked in. I try to clean one now, and I end up bent over double trying to get back to the bedroom to lay down flat for a while. So, everyone around here kicks in and does a little each day, and then we clean them well the night before trash day. So far, none of the felines are complaining... and believe me, mine are very vocal about things like this!

We tried two different litter robot kinds of machines... but I think this was when they first began to come out. Both of them were a heck of a lot more problems than just scooping the box. Crap on the rollers to be cleaned off... machinery stopping. Sent the first one back, convinced it was simply a lemon... but damn, the second one did the same thing. Still... I look longingly at some of the new ones out on the market. But no way could I ever justify the price on our budget!

buzzycrumbhunger

(1,605 posts)
6. Over the years...
Sat Dec 6, 2025, 05:32 PM
Dec 6

I’ve simplified my life by getting a three-layer litter box with two trays and an extra one with holes so you can sift out the lumps, the litter falls into the clean tray, and then you clean the first and stack it on the bottom.

I also use the clumping crystal litter so we can scoop the crap out a couple times a day, leaving the clean litter (if you let it sit, the damp crystal litter kind of welds itself to the plastic tray, so scooping often helps eliminate that). I keep both near the toilet so it’s no effort to scoop as you’re already sitting there.

I use what’s essentially a diaper genie for the stuff I scoop, so there’s really no odor. Clean it out once a week and you’re good.

We have two cats—one huge and one tiny—and if we had room for more, I think more than one poop station would be a must.

I’ve heard from someone who went the $700 route for a robotic litter box and she complains about it a lot, not the hands-off solution she expected.

Hobbes and Pixie, my prolific poopers:

buzzycrumbhunger

(1,605 posts)
14. Yup!
Sat Dec 6, 2025, 05:48 PM
Dec 6

I think I got it at Petco for about $15. Two regular trays and the sifting tray is visible in this picture.

I’ve also tried the closed-in boxes that you roll over and the lumps fall into a small tray you pull out of the top front. Colossal PITA and Hobbes (tipping the scales at 17-18 lb) didn’t handle the size well.

buzzycrumbhunger

(1,605 posts)
17. YW!
Sat Dec 6, 2025, 05:59 PM
Dec 6

Note the Litter Genie is identical to the Diaper Genie, except that it comes with a poop scoop. I know I’ve seen Diaper Genies in thrift shops so that could be a cheaper way to go than buying a new cat one. I’ve also started just using regular small trash bags inside that instead of the weird roll of plastic tubing that you have to knot at both ends. Either way, it’s a bit of a hassle except that it closes off the cat poop until you can empty it so no one has to see or smell your furbabies’ works of art.

Response to buzzycrumbhunger (Reply #14)

Freddie

(10,040 posts)
16. I also use a sifting box
Sat Dec 6, 2025, 05:58 PM
Dec 6

Just sift it daily (takes 2 minutes) and change the litter entirely about once a month. My 2 boys (one of whom is 22 lb) are happy. I like Arm & Hammer Clump & Slide for multiple cats. Litter does not stick to the tray, just slides right off.

iemanja

(57,314 posts)
42. Do you think a crystal litter would work with that sifting system?
Fri Dec 12, 2025, 02:20 PM
Dec 12

The slide and clump litter has gotten smelly.

I did just slide out all the clumps.

buzzycrumbhunger

(1,605 posts)
25. Thanks!
Sat Dec 6, 2025, 07:12 PM
Dec 6

We had an old lady who ran the PO at college, Hazel. They finally made her retire in her late 90s, and she had started this quilt and never finished. I inherited it from her and somehow, managed to piece it together and put it together—all by hand.

Dear_Prudence

(1,019 posts)
24. Disposable box?
Sat Dec 6, 2025, 07:11 PM
Dec 6

Amazon has disposable cardboard boxes for about $4 each. Maybe Chewy has them cheaper. So you just toss the entire box out, no sifting dirty litter. I used these when I had my son take care of the cats while I traveled. If the automatic one you are looking at is $650 dollars, that amount of money would buy a lot of disposable ones. Maybe you could start out with disposable ones, then figure out what permanent litter box system is worth a large investment. Anyway, a cat is a wonderful pet. I wish you all the best!

iemanja

(57,314 posts)
28. I decided to go with a sifting litter box
Sat Dec 6, 2025, 07:18 PM
Dec 6

It costs $20. The litter is the most expensive part of the system. It's made by Arm and Hammer.

bamagal62

(4,323 posts)
34. Disposable boxes are
Sat Dec 6, 2025, 07:57 PM
Dec 6

The bomb. Natures miracle, although more expensive, last forever and do not leak. They stopped making them for about a year and I had to buy the cheap ones that lasted about 4 days. Natures miracle boxes last weeks and do not smell!!! My cats upstairs box rarely gets used and it’s been there for 2 months. Paper litter is sooooo much better than clumping.

Nanuke

(900 posts)
30. We use the litter boxes with the high sides so kitties can't get litter on the floor when they dig.
Sat Dec 6, 2025, 07:24 PM
Dec 6

Blue Owl

(58,119 posts)
31. Recently switched to a brand of litter called "Catalyst"
Sat Dec 6, 2025, 07:24 PM
Dec 6

And definitely recommend it to any cat owner. Not sure how it works in a self-cleaning box, but the litter is so lightweight and odor-free that I don't mind scooping out the box a few times a week and it is also very eco-friendly and inexpensive. You can go for months before it is ready to add/replace or change out.

It's mainly sold online (although I've heard some Hy-Vee stores sell it). So it gets delivered to your door, and never a need to lug heavy, wasteful plastic jugs or 40 lb. boxes.

I used to HATE the smell and grossness of clay litter, and this is a world of difference, super quick and easy to clean with a sifting scoop (a metal one with wide slats works best).

https://catalystpet.com/

bamagal62

(4,323 posts)
33. I use a disposable litter box.
Sat Dec 6, 2025, 07:51 PM
Dec 6

And, I use paper litter instead of clumping litter. It lasts at least 3 weeks before I have to throw it away and get a new one. I don’t scoop the pee, only the poop. Natures miracle has disposable boxes that last several weeks or more, depending on the cat.
The paper litter does not smell. Kittens can sometimes try to ingest the clumping litter. If they do, it swells in their intestines and causes a blockage which can involve surgery. Paper litter does not do that. So, if you plan to get a kitten, the clumping litter can be dangerous and expensive if they have to have a blockage removed. I have a cat that eats all kind of weird shit. I cannot have a Christmas tree!
So, I’m happy that someone alerted me to the dangers of clumping litter. I buy Fresh News litter and natures miracle disposable boxes.

bamagal62

(4,323 posts)
35. Also, one more warning about
Sat Dec 6, 2025, 08:03 PM
Dec 6

Clumping litter. If your dog has a propensity to eat cat poop and if they get to the litter and ingest the clumping litter, it will expand in their intestines and will need surgery. It can also be deadly if you don’t know that they ate the poop/litter. Beware of clumping litter.
It hardens and expands and can cause a lot of problems and a lot of expense.

iemanja

(57,314 posts)
36. If I do get a cat, I'll go with a sifting box rather than clumping
Sat Dec 6, 2025, 08:11 PM
Dec 6

There is a litter called slide made by Arm and Hammer that goes through their sifting box. I don't, however, have a dog anymore.

CountAllVotes

(22,055 posts)
40. The clumping litter can be heavy
Sat Dec 6, 2025, 09:44 PM
Dec 6

My late cat Andreas was allergic to it. It hurt his paws and it was back to Tidy Cats.



iemanja

(57,314 posts)
41. Thanks everyone. I ordered the litter box
Sat Dec 6, 2025, 10:48 PM
Dec 6

and other supplies. I also sent an inquiry about a cat on Petfinder. So hopefully I'll have a cat in a week or so.

Latest Discussions»Culture Forums»Pets»Help with litter boxes