"Pro-life" identity politics: GOP's sudden support of abortion shows it was never about policy

[marmar]

"Pro-life" identity politics: GOP's sudden support of abortion shows it was never about policy
Dramatic shifts in abortion polls illustrate how MAGA just wanted a way to bash women

By Amanda Marcotte
Senior Writer
Published October 3, 2024 5:54AM (EDT)


(Salon) Before Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health, the Supreme Court decision that ended abortion rights, it was a truism in the Beltway press that Americans were "bitterly divided" on abortion. Driven by polls that mostly asked people if they are "pro-life" or "pro-choice," journalists portrayed Republican voters as strongly opposed to abortion for moral and religious reasons. So it's quite the shocker to see recent polls show that a plurality — and in many cases, the majority — of Republicans plan to vote for abortion rights in various state ballot initiatives this November.

....(snip)....

What's going on here isn't especially confusing. Prior to Dobbs, calling yourself "pro-life" was a low-cost way for Republican voters to tell a story where they are morally upright heroes while casting feminists, urban liberals, college kids, and racial minorities as oversexed heathens. When abortion is legal, it's easy to condemn other people's abortions as a matter of "convenience" or say they're "using it for birth control" or employ other euphemisms for promiscuity, while quietly believing the abortions you and your friends get are justified.

....(snip)....

It was an outrageous lie by insinuation, but why he lied is not mysterious. Vance understands that his voters want to hear a pretty story where people like themselves will get to have abortions, but those other people — imagined to be "sluts" and "welfare queens" — will not. The problem for him and Trump, as this polling shows, is that the cold, hard reality of abortion bans is hard to ignore, now that they're law and not just an abstraction. Post-Dobbs, "abortion" isn't just a way for MAGA voters to gloat about their self-defined moral superiority. Instead, they realize that the bans apply to MAGA and non-MAGA alike. It's shifted from cheap identity politics to real-world impacts. As these polling changes demonstrate, their actual policy preference has started to eclipse what used to move them, which was culture war nonsense.

....(snip)....

Democrats are often accused by the pundits of being the ones who practice "identity politics," usually when they note the real world impacts of sexism, racism, and homophobia on real people. But what Republicans do is pure identity politics, a politics about ego and identity that is disconnected from material implications. Their propaganda apparatus encourages white people to wallow in sick urban legends about cat-eating immigrants, which creates the temporary thrill of feeling superior without doing anything substantive to improve their lives. Or to complain about imaginary "loose" women who use abortions as "birth control." Or to get mad about "cancel culture" or make-believe slights from liberals. ..................(more)

https://www.salon.com/2024/10/03/pro-life-identity-politics-gops-sudden-support-of-abortion-shows-it-was-never-about-policy/

[duncang]

1. Knr

[Vogon_Glory]

2. I'm not sure that the Republicans can back away from absolutist abortion bans

I’m not sure Republican politicians can back away from absolutist abortion bans. While many Republican voters and many Republican voters may be pro-choice (at least when it comes to their own personal circumstances), the fact remains that the anti-abortion movement remains the best-organized, best-motivated, and most determined voting block within many state and local Republican Party organizations.

In short, they’re motivated and they vote. (They’re also numerous). And they will continue to do so and be so for years to come. The problem is structural, since anti-abortion activists have such an outsize influence within the Republican Party. Any aspiring Republican politico seeking to win their party’s nomination to office will have to toe the line and toe it exactly. Aspiring Republican politicos may make positive noises about choice and allowing access to birth control before Election Day, but in order to keep the anti-abortion bloc happy, they’ll have to vote AGAINST allowing access to abortion and FOR restrictions on contraceptives once they’re elected. They have no choice: toe the line or out they go.