General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsThe best take I've seen on Bad Bunny's halftime show
The author of this is Michael Garrett, a state senator in the North Carolina General Assembly. You can read his original post on his Facebook page, along with thousands of very moving and uplifting responses, here: https://www.facebook.com/share/17Z4SYrjpy/?mibextid=wwXIfr
He sang every single word in Spanish. Every. Single. Word. He danced through sugarcane fields built on a football field in California while the President of the United States sat somewhere calling it disgusting. Lady Gaga came out and did the salsa. Ricky Martin lit up the night. A couple got married on the field. He handed his Grammy, the one he won eight days ago for Album of the Year, to a little boy who looked up at him the way every child looks up when they dare to believe the world has a place for them.
And then this man, this son of a truck driver and a schoolteacher from Vega Baja, Puerto Rico, stood on the biggest stage on the planet and said God bless America.
And then he started naming them.
Chile. Argentina. Uruguay. Paraguay. Bolivia. Peru. Ecuador. Brazil. Colombia. Venezuela. Panama. Costa Rica. Nicaragua. Honduras. El Salvador. Guatemala. Mexico. Cuba. Dominican Republic. Jamaica. The United States. Canada. And then, his voice breaking with everything he carries, Mi patria, Puerto Rico. Seguimos aquí. My homeland, Puerto Rico. We are still here.
The flags came. Every single one of them. Carried across that field by dancers and musicians while the jumbotron lit up with the only words that mattered: THE ONLY THING MORE POWERFUL THAN HATE IS LOVE.
I teared up. Im not ashamed to say it. I sat on my couch and I wept because THAT is the America I believe in. That is the American story, not the sanitized, gated, English-only version that small and frightened people try to sell us. The REAL one. The messy, beautiful, multilingual, multicolored, courageous one. The one that has always been built by hands that speak every language and pray in every tongue and come from every corner of this hemisphere.
That is the America I want Jack and Charlotte to know. That when the moment came, when the whole world was watching, a Puerto Rican kid who grew up to become the most-streamed artist on Earth stood in front of 100 million people, sang in his mothers language, blessed every nation in the Americas, and spiked a football that read Together, we are America into the ground. Not with anger. With joy. With love so big it made hate look exactly as small as it is.
And what did the President do? He called it absolutely terrible. He said nobody understands a word this guy is saying. He called it a slap in the face to our Country. The leader of the free world watched a celebration of love, culture, and everything this hemisphere has given to the world, and all he could see was something foreign. Something threatening. Something disgusting.
Let that sink into your bones.
The man who is supposed to represent all of us looked at the flags of our neighbors, heard the language of 500 million Americans across this hemisphere, and felt attacked. Thats not strength. Thats not patriotism. That is poverty of the soul.
And then there was the Turning Point show. Kid Rock in a college arena in North Dakota. Three million viewers watching a man who once wrote a song about liking underage girls perform as the family-friendly alternative to a Puerto Rican artist celebrating love. They called it the All-American Halftime Show, as if America has a velvet rope. As if this country belongs to some of us and not all of us. As if you need to sing in English to count.
Heres what I want to say to everyone who posted about that show tonight, who shared it proudly, who turned away from Bad Bunnys celebration because it was in Spanish and the flags werent only red, white, and blue:
Your children will see those posts. Your grandchildren will find them. The internet doesnt forget. And one day, when the history of this moment is written, when our kids and their kids look back at 2026 the way we look back at the people who stood on the wrong side of every bridge and every march and every moment that mattered, they will know exactly where you stood. They will see who chose Kid Rock over a hemisphere of flags. They will see who called love disgusting. And they will carry that knowledge the way all of us carry the knowledge of what our ancestors did when they were tested.
I dont say that with anger. I say it with sadness. Because hate is an inheritance nobody asks for, and yet it gets passed down just the same.
Bad Bunny didnt say ICE out tonight. He didnt need to. He just showed the whole world what America looks like when we are not afraid of each other. When culture is shared, not policed. When language is music, not a threat. When a flag from every nation in this hemisphere can walk across a football field together and the only words you need are the ones he gave us:
The only thing more powerful than hate is love.
Over 100 million people saw that tonight.
And no Truth Social post can take it away.
VGuerra276
(88 posts)So well said!
Easterncedar
(5,786 posts)Thanks
barbtries
(31,223 posts)whose speech regarding the republican gerrymandering was so powerful the republicans had it purged from the record.
yardwork
(69,108 posts)livetohike
(24,108 posts)Ive seen it shared on Facebook many times today. Now if MAGA will read this and actually think about it, hopefully we will see some changes.
D_Master81
(2,400 posts)You said MAGA and read and think so no that wont happen
highplainsdem
(60,876 posts)Deuxcents
(26,079 posts)If the message and the music didnt get ya moving, nothing will.
Conjuay
(2,975 posts)Before you close the lid, put on some Latin jazz, and crank it up.
If I don't react, go ahead and seal the box.
Pluvious
(5,314 posts)hlthe2b
(113,240 posts)I liked it. That said, I love world music and exploration of world cultures--having traveled quite a bit and worked overseas in several areas of the world. I also am a highly visual person so the theatrics and Broadway Musical or cinema-like effects were appealing to me. That said, I know from speaking to some others -who are at least politically liberal and culturally tolerant enough to be open to Bad Bunny- had some challenges. Neither had ever listened to him before and were not the target audience for such theatrical type performances and just found it difficult to follow along. No. I am not making excuses for them.
Clearly those listening and not watching would be met with a special challenge--especially if they did not speak Spanish. My understanding is that sports radio this morning was full of those reactions--an no, not all from those who cater to MAGA types
Clearly, many detractors have forgotten who has performed at the Super Bowl in the past and how they might have appealed to only a segment of the population (e.g., young versus older, male versus female, Pop versus Rap fan audiences, etc.)
I am glad NFL spotlighted Bad Bunny and Latino-specifically Puerto Rico culture. Hopefully they won't be reticent to do similar in the future.
yardwork
(69,108 posts)I can think of numerous examples from the past and I imagine you can as well.
One of the many admirable aspects of last night's performance was that it did not cater to non-fans - it was a sincere and authentic representation of this performer - yet at the same time the message was one of inclusion and celebration.
Very few Super Bowl halftime performances hit that balance. This one did, exceptionally well. It's probably why he's such a popular performer.
SomedayKindaLove
(1,177 posts)Id expect a lot more of this.
FakeNoose
(40,769 posts)I'm glad we're taking a break from football for a while.
NNadir
(37,557 posts)Frankly the Bad Bunny thing went over my little head, but this post made me understand what I was failing to understand.
Let me send a heart.
yardwork
(69,108 posts)NNadir
(37,557 posts)niyad
(130,571 posts)crazylikafox
(2,906 posts)Thank you for posting
Grim Chieftain
(1,434 posts)I hope everyone will take a moment to read this. Wow. Happy tears here.
HappyH
(195 posts)An excellent take on Bad Bunny's performance. You do not have to understand Spanish to feel the love and joy in Benito's music.
flamingdem
(40,833 posts)I think it was wonderful but not that different from other latin music shows I've seen.
The call out to other countries is standard as is some of the hyper masculinity in
the lyrics, etc.
The venue and the time we're in are very different however. So it mattered. A lot.
If there wasn't so much at stake I would have preferred less focus on Puerto Rico
and more about the injustices happening now with Ice.
A lot of people wanted to see the little boy as Liam but it was a younger version of
himself.
Maybe open to interpretation.
malaise
(294,261 posts)Thats not strength. Thats not patriotism. That is poverty of the soul.
What soul? The racist vulgarian convict is a brainless, bad fitting suit devoid of decency, humanity, shame.or a soul.
Fuck that fucking fuck.
Cirsium
(3,681 posts)Thanks for posting that. Just thanks.
Corny, smiley, I know.
I was so moved by that performance...I can't find the words.
yardwork
(69,108 posts)TygrBright
(21,326 posts)Being a nation of immigrants should be our source of pride, strength, and hope. As our ancestors were welcomed and helped by the First Nations of America, and to my everlasting shame, those same ancestors repaid love with hate, we are perpetuating a cycle which will forever keep America from becoming truly great.
sadly,
Bright
StarryNite
(12,031 posts)It gives me hope.
StarryNite
(12,031 posts)but couldn't fully express.
yardwork
(69,108 posts)StarryNite
(12,031 posts)I'm now following his FB page.
democrank
(12,416 posts)These uplifting words tell a story much different than the vile, abusive hate Trump spews. It was a pleasure to read and a pleasure to feel. Thank you so much, yardwork.
kwolf68
(8,311 posts)Love will eventually win.
Luciferous
(6,569 posts)people
(836 posts)Maru Kitteh
(31,430 posts)that small and frightened people try to sell us.
Goonch
(4,404 posts)
CousinIT
(12,370 posts)Thanks!
popsdenver
(1,882 posts)A profound and majestic statement...................
(Trump was just pissed off that Bad Bunny didn't give HIM the Gold trophy, and esp since he gave it to a young mexican child instead...)
Paper Roses
(7,624 posts)We are thankful for people like you who spread our thoughts with such wonderful, thoughtful comments,
yardwork
(69,108 posts)I was impressed with his thoughts.
Cha
(317,772 posts)take on Bad Bunny's NFL's Half Time Show.. I didn't see it, but his view gave a brilliant sense of what went on. Amazing!
yardwork
💔☮️🌺🌻🕯️🕊️💜
dem4decades
(13,873 posts)Bluetus
(2,499 posts)And I am not talking about the swine in the White House with the dirty diapers. I am talking about the NFL. Maybe they are the 800 Pound Gorilla rather than the elephant metaphor.
Be that as it may, my point is that the NFL has been notoriously right-wing forever. Every team is owned by billionaires. They celebrate every game with a jingoistic display of militarism with grotesquely large flags, and aircraft flyovers when possible
And this is the organization that lost its shit when one player decided to kneel during the national anthem That is the NFL, fucking right-wingers, today's plantations owners from top to bottom. That's who they are, most of them anyway.
So, how could they have programmed Green Day, Bad Bunny, Lady Gaga, knowing they were going to bring a message 100X as pointed as Colin Kaeppernick?
Well, there is one and only one thing the NFL owners believe more strongly that the authoritarianism that gives them any privilege they could ever want. And that one thing is money.
They programmed the world's grandest protest because the NFL knows how to read the room. And that is a good thing. 2026 is an inflection point, and the NFL doesn't want to end up on the wrong side of that. Simple as that.
sheshe2
(96,656 posts)I am going to bookmark your OP so I can read it over and over again.
Thank you, yardwork. 🩷
Alice B.
(722 posts)That is all.
Clouds Passing
(7,512 posts)HeartsCanHope
(1,559 posts)Solly Mack
(96,651 posts)Jean Genie
(541 posts)God bless you, Yardwork. And god bless Bad Bunny!
yardwork
(69,108 posts)I'm so glad to have this kind, thoughtful space.
pansypoo53219
(22,963 posts)but i wanna know how he found a young male dancer from milwaukee to dance w/ him too.
tulipsandroses
(8,190 posts)and just went to eat their Guacamole, Salsa and chips until the game resumed.
Of course Salsa and Guacamole are All American. So American, you can't watch an All American game without it.
stillspkg
(174 posts)I so looked forward to the Super Bowl Half-time show. I recently listened to some Bad Bunny songs and really like the sound of his voice. Then came the half-time show. The staging & and overall message were great. It was but lost on me though because of the lurid dancing. I've since learned about dwerking, pwerking and bwerking. I do not feel enlightened. I feel betrayed.
Faux pas
(16,236 posts)thucythucy
(9,063 posts)I remember President Obama saying, "It's like they're proud of their ignorance."
Trump is indeed proud, not only of his ignorance, but also of his hate. He is especially proud of his ability to inflict pain, as are so many of his followers and enablers. From shooting dogs to caging children to assaulting young girls to attacking elders and people with disabilities, saying and doing harmful, hateful things is the biggest thrill of their stunted lives.
I would like to believe that love is stronger than hate, I really would. And that truth will prevail over lies. But at the moment...
For me, everything will depend on what happens in November. Will we have free and fair elections? And will the American people finally turn their backs on all this monstrous hate?
Trump is the distillation of every worst instinct and facet of the human soul and character. But, hopefully, at some point everyone will understand the true meaning of the words he insists on saying.
